Kerby Rychel had the lone goal for the Spitfires (8-7-1-1), who lost their fifth straight decision.
It didn't take the Colts long to jump on the Spits, as Scheifele opened the scoring just 48 seconds into the game. Two more goals followed by the time the period was old.
John Cullen allowed three goals on the first four shots and was pulled in favour of Jack Campbell.
The game featured a massive fight in the game's final minutes with multiple players from each side on the ice.
SCORING
FIRST PERIOD
BAR SCHIEFELE (2) (PEARSON, MCNEILL) 0:48
BAR PEARSON (12) (BEYERS, BEHENNA)
BAR BEYERS (3) (EKBLAD, SCHIEFELE)
BAR BEHENNA (8) (SCHIEFELE, BEYERS)
SECOND PERIOD
THIRD PERIOD
BAR BEHENNA (9) (PEARSON, SCHEIFELE)
SHOTS